Romance Writers of America is now involved. Amazon, as RWA’s request, is no longer removing books and reviews that were purported to be in violation of trademark (which is impossible, since a single word cannot be trademarked).
Here’s more on the train wreck in progress.
Victoria Strauss on SFWA’s Writers Beware blog is “Weighing In”:
If you haven’t heard the c*ck-up about trademarking a word (which can’t be done, unless the word is used in a non-usual sense, like Apple Computers), then here’s a brief summary, courtesy of Courtney Milan’s twitter stream.
*The Plot Types will take two blogs. (Sorry. Not.) Come back on the 10th for the finish line of this post.
Plot is the foundation of all story.
The key to any construction job is the foundation. People buy houses based on the square footage they need and the look of the life they want. The buyers don’t consider the state of the foundation; that’s the job of the builder. And the foundation is buried in the ground, unseen, doing its job without any acclaim or gratitude or blessing. Without a strong foundation, however, the whole structure will fall apart.
So it goes with story.
People may love the characters and chatter excitedly about events and the genre tropes, but everything—EVERYTHING—in that story will fall apart if the foundation is not solid. Should story-tellers neglect plot, the story suffers, and not even the most wonderful characters and stupendous events and twisty tropes can rescue it.